1. Right Answer: B
Explanation: B is the best answer. A gap analysis should be conducted to identify whether the benefits are in line with the organization's strategy. A is incorrect, because the correlation between benefits and turnover has not been established. C is incorrect. Twelve months is an ample amount of time to provide data on the success of the package. D is incorrect. This type of evaluation is based on opinions and feelings and is very subjective. However, it can be a part of the gap analysis.
2. Right Answer: A
Explanation: A business case is a request for the allocation of resources to implement a solution to a problem or a plan to take advantage of an opportunity. Strong business cases are aligned with the organization's strategy and include a cost-benefit analysis of alternative solutions to the problem or opportunity, including taking no action. The business case usually includes discussion of risks. A cost-benefit analysis is not a business case but is an important part of a business case. Market research may be an input into the business case analysis. A scenario-based test would project the results of a business plan under differents sets of variables (e.g., supply prices, market share).
3. Right Answer: C
Explanation: C is the best response. It is important for HR to demonstrate its strategic value by developing solutions and an overall approach that will address all identified problem areas and will lead to achieving business objectives. A and B are incorrect. While these may be tactical steps to address specific problems, these actions should be taken further downstream in the process after the strategy and action plan have been established. D is incorrect. Although the eventual decision could be to share the findings with all the employees, the HR manager should first share the findings with the executive committee. Moreover, it is not within the purview of the HR manager to make this decision independently.
4. Right Answer: A
Explanation: A is the best response. It is important to present the HR business case for a change in terms of financial benefits and return on investment (ROI). Part of the ROI analysis should include scenarios of different options or solutions, including the costs of rebuilding the workforce vs. training the current workforce. This response would provide the executive committee member with a hard-data comparison of the options being considered. B is incorrect. The HR manager should conduct an in-depth analysis and present all possible scenarios and solutions to the entire executive committee. Making a decision based on only one opinion, without any data to support the decision, would be illogical. C is incorrect. This is an incomplete rationale, as it focuses only on the cost of a new, better-qualified workforce but does not compare those costs to the proposed costs of the initiatives. D is incorrect. This is a weak response, given that the HR manager does not effectively communicate the HR position and does not actively defend the proposal but rather passes it on to someone else to defend it.
5. Right Answer: A
Explanation: A is the best response. The HR problems were originally identified by the CEO and the executive committee because of the decline in the quality of service. This has been established as the critical metric to measure the performance and success of the organization. B is incorrect. Although turnover rate is an important metric that illustrates what percentage of employees leave an organization during a period of time, it will not assist with the organization's current focus, quality of service, nor is employee turnover a pressing issue at this juncture. C is incorrect. This is a good measurement to help determine HR staffing levels, but it is not tied directly to the organization's overall success. D is incorrect. A training completion rate metric will show only how many people have attended training. It is not tied directly to the organization's overall success.
6. Right Answer: B
Explanation: B is the best response. When managing a change, ensuring effective communication throughout the organization is critical for success. A two-pronged approach helps ensure that the right level of detail is being communicated based on the individuals' roles and the degree of impact the new program will have. The centralized messages are generic and relevant to the entire organization. Training the supervisors and managers enables them to deliver specific messages to each of their direct reports individually to help them understand the impact and what the change means to them. A is incorrect. Although all-employee meetings are helpful, a one-time approach to announce changes of this magnitude will leave employees with many questions unanswered. C is incorrect. Web-based information is likely helpful support after the rollout of the changes, but it is not a stand-alone option for communication. D is incorrect. Sending an e-mail communication and offering the employees a chance to ask questions can be a part of the two-pronged communication strategy; however, this will not suffice as a stand-alone option.
7. Right Answer: A
Explanation: While it may be tempting to do the expedient thing and meet the company's promises, this action will have a negative effect on employee morale and retention, and it could invite union-organizing activity. Using the Consultation competency, HR can explore other alternatives that will be more effective and acceptable to employees.
8. Right Answer: C
Explanation: HR professionals should function as consultants to managers, which would involve getting their input and offering to support them and/or answer questions as needed. It would not involve having their bosses make threats, micromanaging, or overstepping boundaries—particularly not in a way that would suggest that HR would do a better job of evaluating their employees than they would.
9. Right Answer: C
Explanation: Based on this force-field analysis, the group can decide to pursue opportunities with scores showing favorability for change or avoid changes that face very strong resistance. They might also use analysis results in deciding how to allocate resources to mitigate negative risks and enhance opportunities. Force-field analysis tries to identify conditions needed to make change possible.
10. Right Answer: A
Explanation: A is the best answer, as it provides an opportunity for the HR director to use the Consultation competency to discuss how the changes in the business and the marketplace affect the hiring process, thus providing guidance on how to navigate those challenges. B is not the best answer, because it does not provide a viable solution to the problem or an opportunity to provide guidance to the managers. C is not the best answer, because it does not provide the opportunity for the HR director to address the concerns and provide education. D is not the best answer, since it delegates the responsibility to the HR director's boss and the HR director is not demonstrating competency.
Leave a comment